Subject: Defining democracy

The “crisis” of democracy is a crisis of representation. New parties, some of which are populist in troublingly illiberal ways, are arising from this moment. The danger that they pose is not that they are antidemocratic, but that they are antiliberal.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

The Liberalism of Refuge

Liberal societies are those which offer refuge from the very people they empower—through individual choice, mobility, and the possibility of exit. This is the form of liberty that most clearly elevates the liberal project.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

Liberalism as Fortress and Prison

The power of liberalism—though limited and never revered—enables it to serve as refuge while taming the demons of liberal society.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

The Limits of Liberalism

The liberal emphasis on unhindered mobility comes with costs, particularly for those unable to leave.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

Liberal Tolerance for an Intolerant Age

What distinguishes liberal societies from all others is that they tolerate immoral behavior. It is this tolerance that protects us not just from our leaders but ourselves.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

A Refuge from Liberalism?

The belief we can “escape” remains a part of the liberal imagination. In truth, it is realized in the form of detachment from any community, an exodus without refuge.

April 2024, Volume 35, Issue 2

A Reply to My Critics

A liberal society must reckon the demands of the common good, while offering what we most crave—something worth sacrificing for.

January 2024, Volume 35, Issue 1

Why Democracy Survives Populism

Populism is a mortal threat to liberal democracy, but it rarely hits the mark. The evidence shows that these would-be strongmen require an extraordinary set of circumstances to succeed, which is why they so rarely do.

October 2022, Volume 33, Issue 4

The Politics of Enemies

Democracy’s meaning has always been contested. Letting that struggle become a battle between existential foes risks upending the whole democratic project.

July 2022, Volume 33, Issue 3

Cancel Toqueville?

Does the author of the nineteenth-century classic, Democracy in America, still matter?

October 2021, Volume 32, Issue 4

Trading Democracy for Governance

Majorities across the globe claim to support democratic rule, but their definitions of it vary widely. A look at where publics are willing to exchange their democratic principles for better results—and where they will not.

July 2017, Volume 28, Issue 3

The Pipe Dream of Undemocratic Liberalism

A look at liberal democracy’s complex historical evolution shows that elite fantasies of liberalism without democracy are ill-founded. Authoritarian legacies and democratic deficits lie at the core of trends that threaten liberal rights.

October 2015, Volume 26, Issue 4

Exploring “Non-Western Democracy”

Often called for but seldom defined with any precision, “non-Western democracy” could end up giving cover to authoritarianism, but also could allow potentially useful democratic innovations to be tried and tested.

October 2015, Volume 26, Issue 4

The Evolution of Political Order

A review of Political Order and Political Decay: From the Industrial Revolution to the Globalization of Democracy by Francis Fukuyama.

July 2014, Volume 25, Issue 3

V-Dem: A New Way to Measure Democracy

In order to mark democracy’s progress and to inform policy, we need to be able to measure democracy in sufficient detail. The V-Dem Project aims to deliver exactly such a tool.

April 2014, Volume 25, Issue 2

Democratic Parliamentary Monarchies

How do democracies emerge from monarchies? In an essay that eminent political scientist Juan J. Linz was working on when he passed away in October 2013, he and his coauthors draw lessons from the European experience about whether and how Arab monarchies might aid or resist democratic development.

October 2013, Volume 24, Issue 4

The Third Wave: Inside the Numbers

Is democracy threatened by a “reverse wave”? Examining regional patterns and distinguishing between different types of democracy gives us a new basis for assessing this question. Listen to the podcast with authors Jørgen Møller and Svend-Erik Skaaning [mp3]

July 2011, Volume 22, Issue 3

Comparing Latin Democracies

A review of The Quality of Democracy in Latin America, edited by Daniel H. Levine and José E. Molina.

October 2010, Volume 21, Issue 4

The Meanings of Democracy: Introduction

Read the full essay here.

October 2010, Volume 21, Issue 4

The Meanings of Democracy: Anchoring the “D-Word” in Africa

Efforts to do comparative research on political attitudes have been complicated by varying understandings of “democracy.” The Afrobarometer is exploring new techniques to overcome this difficulty.

October 2010, Volume 21, Issue 4

The Meanings of Democracy: Solving an Asian Puzzle

Over the years, the Asian Barometer Survey has yielded some surprising results. A new typological analysis helps to make sense of them.

October 2010, Volume 21, Issue 4

The Meanings of Democracy: The Shadow of Confucianism

How can Chinese claim strongly to support both democracy and their authoritarian regime? The answer may lie in a Confucian concept of democracy.

October 2010, Volume 21, Issue 4

The Meanings of Democracy: What Arabs Think

Arabs express a clear preference for democracy, which they define in ways similar to citizens elsewhere in the world. But their authoritarian regimes are not listening.

April 2010, Volume 21, Issue 2

What Makes Legislatures Strong?

A review of The Handbook of National Legislatures: A Global Survey by M. Steven Fish and Matthew Kroenig, and Legislative Power in Emerging African Democracies edited by Joel D. Barkan.

January 2010, Volume 21, Issue 1

Twenty Years of Postcommunism: Freedom and the State

This is a central problem—perhaps the central problem—for classical liberal theory and its crucial distinction between the state of nature and the civil state. Which is better for liberty: nature or the state?

October 2009, Volume 20, Issue 4

Poverty, Inequality, and Democracy (II): Does Electoral Democracy Boost Economic Equality?

The recent global progress of democracy has been accompanied by increasing economic inequality. What are the implications for the quality of democracy and for its ability to endure?

April 2009, Volume 20, Issue 2

Religion and Democracy

The secularization hypothesis has failed, and failed spectacularly. We must find a new paradigm to help us understand the complexities of the relationship between religion and democracy.

April 2009, Volume 20, Issue 2

Reading Russia: Tools of Autocracy

Read the full essay here. Arguably a flawed democracy in the 1990s, Russia took a distinctly authoritarian turn under President Vladimir Putin from 2000 to 2008. The country now lives under a façade democracy that barely conceals the political and administrative dominance of a self-interested bureaucratic corporation. The regime manufactures consent by means of three…

January 2009, Volume 20, Issue 1

Democracy Assistance: Political vs. Developmental?

Democracy-aid providers are moving away from one-size-fits-all strategies and are adapting their programs to diverse political contexts. Two distinct overall approaches to assisting democracy have emerged in response.

October 2008, Volume 19, Issue 4

Poverty, Inequality, and Democracy: The Latin American Experience

"The Latin American Experience” argues that democratic stability requires policies that limit the society’s degree of substantive economic and social inequality.

July 2008, Volume 19, Issue 3

Islamist Parties and Democracy: Are They Democrats? Does It Matter?

The journalistic and policy communities have been alive with speculation as to whether Islamist groups involved in politics—including Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood and Palestine’s Hamas— are true believers in democracy or calculating pragmatists who, in Steven Cook’s words, are “seeking to use democratic procedures in order to advance an antidemocratic agenda.”

April 2008, Volume 19, Issue 2

Public Opinion and Democratic Legitimacy

Do young democracies have to "deliver the goods" economically in order to win political legitimacy in their citizens' eyes? Public opinion data from Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Arab world suggest some fascinating answers.

January 2008, Volume 19, Issue 1

The Democracy Barometers (Part II): Surveying South Asia

While the people of South Asia, especially those with higher levels of education and exposure to the media, prefer democracy to authoritarianism, they are willing to relax some of the requirements of liberal democracy.

January 2008, Volume 19, Issue 1

The Democracy Barometers (Part II): Attitudes in the Arab World

Findings from the Arab Barometer say little about whether there are likely to be transitions to democracy in the Arab world in the years ahead, but they do offer evidence that citizens' attitudes and values are not the reason that authoritarianism has persisted.

January 2008, Volume 19, Issue 1

The Democracy Barometers (Part II): Latin America’s Diversity of Views

Attitudes toward democracy in Latin America vary from country to country, and within countries between left and right. Public opinion is strongly affected by the success or failure of political leaders in delivering social and economic change.

January 2008, Volume 19, Issue 1

The Role of Ordinary People in Democratization

In order for a country to move beyond mere electoral democracy, ordinary people must acquire resources and values that allow them to pressure elites. Human empowerment is essential for the development of "effective democracy."

October 2007, Volume 18, Issue 4

A Quarter-Century of Promoting Democracy

On 7 June 2007, the National Endowment for Democracy commemorated the twenty-fifth anniversary of the "Westminster Address" with a panel discussion and reception in Madison Hall at the Library of Congress.

October 2007, Volume 18, Issue 4

Understanding Democracy: Data from Unlikely Places

Some skeptics have asked whether ordinary people possess an understanding of democracy that allows them to evaluate it as a form of government. Our research yields three generalizations about popular understanding of democracy.

April 2006, Volume 17, Issue 2

Identity, Immigration, and Liberal Democracy

Contemporary liberal democracies, especially in Western Europe, face a major challenge in integrating Muslim immigrants as citizens of pluralistic societies.

October 2005, Volume 16, Issue 4

Babel in Democratization Studies

Recent works on regime types have led to confusion and a tendency to overstate the differences between established and newer democracies.

July 2005, Volume 16, Issue 3

The New Iraq: Democratic Institutions and Performance

Even after its successful elections, Iraq remains a divided society. Democracy did not create these divisions, but it could be the key to managing them.

July 2005, Volume 16, Issue 3

A Fresh Look at Semipresidentialism: Variations on a Theme

The regime type known as semipresidentialism became a popular choice during the "third wave" of democratization. But some variations of this constitutional arrangement are more conducive to democracy than others

April 2005, Volume 16, Issue 2

Scholarship and Statesmanship

Seymour Martin Lipset’s contributions to political science and sociology are not theoretical achievements alone, but reflect his keenly practical moral awareness, his understanding of leadership, and his great love of democracy as the finest form of government ever devised.

April 2005, Volume 16, Issue 2

The Rise of “Muslim Democracy”

The incentives created by competitive elections in a number of Muslim-majority countries are fueling a political trend that roughly resembles the rise of Christian Democracy in twentieth-century Europe

April 2005, Volume 16, Issue 2

Challenge and Change in East Asia: Is Democracy the Only Game in Town?

In three of the six democracies surveyed by the East Asia Barometer, a majority of respondents prefer democracy to its alternatives. In the other three, however, a lingering nostalgia for authoritarianism stands in the way of democratic consolidation.

April 2005, Volume 16, Issue 2

Lipset’s Legacy

A review of The Democratic Century by Seymour Martin Lipset and Jason M. Lakin.

April 2005, Volume 16, Issue 2

Freedom’s Edge

A review of The Democratic Advantage: How Democracies Promote Prosperity and Peace by Morton H. Halperin, Joseph T. Siegle, and Michael M. Weinstein.

January 2005, Volume 16, Issue 1

The 2004 Freedom House Survey: Worrisome Signs, Modest Shifts

Modest progress in the muslim-majority countries is complemented by mass mobilization for democracy and freedom in Ukraine. Meanwhile, Russia ranks as Not Free for the first time since the fall of communism.

October 2004, Volume 15, Issue 4

The Quality of Democracy: An Overview

Since most of the world’s sovereign states are now democracies, there is a growing scholarly focus on “good” or “better” democracy, and on how improvements can not only be measured, but encouraged.

October 2004, Volume 15, Issue 4

The Quality of Democracy: Freedom as the Foundation

Freedom has always been integral to democracy. How to guard liberty is a question every democratic regime must answer.

October 2004, Volume 15, Issue 4

The Quality of Democracy: Addressing Inequality

Democracy requires robust political equality, but the persistence of social, economic and cultural inequality complicates its realization.

October 2004, Volume 15, Issue 4

The Quality of Democracy: A Skeptical Afterword

Asking what makes a good democracy is a noble and sensible enterprise, but it will always point beyond the borders of empirical political science.

July 2004, Volume 15, Issue 3

Russian Democracy in Eclipse: What the Elections Tell Us

President Vladimir Putin's lopsided election victory was assisted by an unlevel electoral playing field, but elections still matter in Russia and they will make more difficult the consolidation of authoritarianism.

July 2004, Volume 15, Issue 3

Russian Democracy in Eclipse: The Limits of Bureaucratic Authoritarianism

Vladimir Putin aspires to be a classic authoritarian modernizer, but in today's globalized world Russia faces challenges that bureaucratic centralization and a traditional strong hand cannot meet.

July 2004, Volume 15, Issue 3

The Perils of Identity Politics

Three leading French political thinkers reflect on why modern democracies tend to forget their own natures, even to the point of encouraging an assertive "identitarianism" that could undermine liberal democracy itself.

April 2004, Volume 15, Issue 2

The Anti-American Century?

The twentieth century has been called "the American century," but it appears that the twenty-first may be dominated by anti-Americanism, an all-purpose ideology that poses a serious obstacle to the progress of democracy.

April 2004, Volume 15, Issue 2

Christianity and Democracy: The Global Picture

That modern democracy first arose with the ambit of Western Christianity is far from an accident. Today, the major Christain communions largely support democracy, even while necessarily retaining the right to criticize democratic decisions in the name fo religious truth claims.

April 2004, Volume 15, Issue 2

Constitutional Design for Divided Societies

Constitution writers in ethnically or otherwise divided countries should focus on designing a system of power-sharing rules and institutions. Studies by political scientists point to a set of basic recommendations that should form a starting point for constitutional negotiations.

January 2004, Volume 15, Issue 1

Europe Moves Eastward: Challenges of EU Enlargement

As it prepares to go from 15 to 25 member states, the EU has improved the prospects for democracy in the East, but nothing about enlargement promises to resolve the vexing issue of democracy within the EU structure itself.

January 2004, Volume 15, Issue 1

Advanced Democracies and the New Politics

The advanced democracies are shifting from a reliance on representation toward a mixed repertoire that includes greater reliance on “direct” and “advocacy” democracy, creating new problems that will require new solutions.

January 2004, Volume 15, Issue 1

Research Report: Does Diversity Hurt Democracy?

It has been claimed in the pages of this journal that a homogeneous society is an advantage when it comes to democratization. How might this suggestion be empirically tested, and with what (perhaps preliminary) results?

October 2003, Volume 14, Issue 4

Making Sense of the EU: The Challenge for Democracy

The EU was founded partly for the purpose of strengthening democracy, but it has been created in a way that is intrinsically not democratic.

October 2001, Volume 12, Issue 4

Public Opinion and Direct Democracy

Direct democracy has come in for praise as being closer to the people’s will than representative democracy. A closer look at the sources of public support, however, reveals some surprises.

July 2001, Volume 12, Issue 3

Two Models of Democracy

A review of Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries by Arend Lijphart and Elections as Instruments of Democracy: Majoritarian and Proportional Views, by G. Bingham Powell, Jr.

October 1999, Volume 10, Issue 4

Redefining Turkey’s Political Center

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Democracy as a Universal Value

In the summer of 1997, I was asked by a leading Japanese newspaper what I thought was the most important thing that had happened in the twentieth century. I found this to be an unusually thought-provoking question, since so many things of gravity have happened over the last hundred years. The European empires, especially the…

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Muslims and Democracy

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Latin America’s Imperiled Progress: Cardoso and the Struggle for Reform in Brazil

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Latin America’s Imperiled Progress: “People Power” in Paraguay

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Latin America’s Imperiled Progress: The Surprising Resilience of Elected Governments

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

From Liberalism to Liberal Democracy

Read the full essay here.

July 1999, Volume 10, Issue 3

Korea After the Crash

Read the full essay here.

January 1999, Volume 10, Issue 1

Buddhism, Asian Values, and Democracy

Read the full essay here.

January 1999, Volume 10, Issue 1

Eastern Europe a Decade Later: The Postcommunist Divide

Read the full essay here.

January 1999, Volume 10, Issue 1

Eastern Europe a Decade Later: Victory Defeated

Read the full essay here.

October 1998, Volume 9, Issue 4

Liberal Voices from China: Liberalism, Equal Status, and Human Rights

Read the full essay here.

October 1998, Volume 9, Issue 4

The New Military Autonomy in Latin America

Read the full essay here.

October 1998, Volume 9, Issue 4

Liberalism of Sorts

A review of After 1989: Morals, Revolution, and Civil Society, by Ralf Dahrendorf.

July 1998, Volume 9, Issue 3

Democracy in the Americas

Read the full essay here.

July 1998, Volume 9, Issue 3

India Defies the Odds: Enduring Another Election

Indians appear to love the practice of democracy so much that they are in danger of overdoing it. In February and March of 1998, the world's largest democracy held its twelfth general election since gaining its independence a half-century ago. The voting was largely fair and peaceful. New, right-of-center rulers led by the Bharatiya Janata…

July 1998, Volume 9, Issue 3

Octavio Paz (1914-1998)

The death of Mexican poet and essayist Octavio Paz on April 20 was (in the words of Mexico’s president Ernesto Zedillo) “an irreplaceable loss for contemporary thought and culture—not just for Latin America but for the entire world.” Born in Mexico City on 31 March 1914, Paz published his first book of poetry while still…

April 1998, Volume 9, Issue 2

African Ambiguities: “No-party Democracy” in Uganda

Read the full essay here.

April 1998, Volume 9, Issue 2

What is Democratic Consolidation?

Read the full essay here.

January 1998, Volume 9, Issue 1

Will China Democratize? Sources of Resistance

Read the full essay here.

January 1998, Volume 9, Issue 1

Democracy and Utopia

Read the full essay here.

January 1998, Volume 9, Issue 1

A Solid Smorgasbord

A review of Democracy’s Victory and Crisis, edited by Axel Hadenius.

October 1997, Volume 8, Issue 4

Islam’s Democratic Essence?

A review of Islam and Democracy, by John L. Esposito and John O. Voll.

April 1997, Volume 8, Issue 2

Hong Kong, Singapore, and “Asian Values”

The Editors’ introduction to “Hong Kong, Singapore, and ‘Asian Values.'”

April 1997, Volume 8, Issue 2

Hong Kong, Singapore, and “Asian Values”: Why Asia Needs Democracy

Read the full essay here.

April 1997, Volume 8, Issue 2

Hong Kong, Singapore, and “Asian Values”: Governance That Works

Read the full essay here.

April 1997, Volume 8, Issue 2

The Democratic Path to Peace

Read the full essay here.

April 1997, Volume 8, Issue 2

Democracy Without Nations?

Read the full essay here.

January 1997, Volume 8, Issue 1

Democracy and Liberty: The Cultural Connection

Read the full essay here.

July 1996, Volume 7, Issue 3

Is the Third Wave Over?

Democracy’s global advance is facing headwinds, but there are still opportunities for progress in pseudodemocratic and authoritarian states.

January 1996, Volume 7, Issue 1

On Modern Individualism

Read the full essay here.

October 1995, Volume 6, Issue 4

The History of the Word “Democracy” in France

Read the full essay here.

April 1995, Volume 6, Issue 2

Transcending the Clash of Cultures: Democracy’s Forgotten Dimension

Read the full essay here.

April 1995, Volume 6, Issue 2

Transcending the Clash of Cultures: Freedom, Development, and Human Worth

Read the full essay here.

January 1995, Volume 6, Issue 1

Democracy’s Future

The Editors’ introduction to “Democracy’s Future.”

January 1995, Volume 6, Issue 1

Democracy’s Future: More Liberal, Preliberal, or Postliberal?

Read the full essay here.